होमAsian CricketRs 27.309 per Unit: The Real Story of Pakistan's Power Tariff Is Buried in Capacity Charges, Not Fuel
Asian Cricket

Rs 27.309 per Unit: The Real Story of Pakistan's Power Tariff Is Buried in Capacity Charges, Not Fuel

**मुख्य उत्तर**: पाकिस्तान के नेपरा ने CY2027 के लिए सीपीपीए-जी के प्रस्तावित औसत पावर परचेज प्राइस (PPP) की सार्वजनिक सुनवाई की, जिसमें 25.883 से 29.255 रुपये प्रति यूनिट के छह परिदृश्य पेश किए गए। आधार-आधारित पीपीपी 27.309 रुपये प्रति यूनिट आंका गया है, लेकिन अंतिम उपभोक्ता टैरिफ नेपरा की समीक्षा के अधीन है। **मुख्य तथ्य**: - नेपरा ने 2027 टैरिफ रीबेसिंग से पहले सीपीपीए-जी के अनुमानों पर सार्वजनिक सुनवाई की। - आधार-आधारित कैपेसिटी चार्ज 14.717 रुपये प्रति यूनिट है, जो ईंधन लागत 10.141 रुपये प्रति यूनिट से अधिक है। - सबसे आशावादी परिदृश्य में पीपीपी 25.883 रुपये प्रति यूनिट, सबसे निराशावादी में 29.255 रुपये प्रति यूनिट। - नेपरा ने कीबोर को 11.70 प्रतिशत से 12 प्रतिशत करने का निर्देश दिया। - उद्योग प्रतिनिधियों ने इंक्रीमेंटल पैकेज निलंबित करने और एफसीए को भविष्य के लिए लागू करने की मांग की। **स्रोत**: स्टेज-1 टेक्स्ट विश्लेषण, नेपरा सार्वजनिक सुनवाई रिपोर्ट, दिसंबर 2026 | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com **संबंधित प्रश्न-उत्तर**: प्रश्न: क्या 8 प्रतिशत बिजली दर वृद्धि को अंतिम मंजूरी मिल गई है? उत्तर: नहीं, 27.309 रुपये प्रति यूनिट का आंकड़ा सीपीपीए-जी का प्रस्ताव है, जो नेपरा की समीक्षा और अंतिम टैरिफ निर्धारण के अधीन है। प्रश्न: कैपेसिटी चार्ज सभी परिदृश्यों में स्थिर क्यों रहता है? उत्तर: कैपेसिटी चार्ज आईपीपी अनुबंधों से जुड़ा है जो उपलब्ध क्षमता के लिए भुगतान है, इसलिए यह ईंधन कीमतों या मांग के उतार-चढ़ाव से सीधे प्रभावित नहीं होता। प्रश्न: महंगी बिजली से मांग पर क्या असर पड़ सकता है? उत्तर: सीपीपीए-जी का संवेदनशीलता परिदृश्य 0.70 प्रतिशत मांग वृद्धि दर्शाता है, जिससे प्रति यूनिट कैपेसिटी चार्ज का बोझ बढ़ सकता है जैसा कि cricsultan.com Energy Cost Transmission Index में दर्शाया गया है।

In a Karachi hearing room that afternoon, there was a strange kind of silence. Officials from the Central Power Purchasing Agency (CPPA-G) were flashing six different numbers on screen — from Rs 25.883 to Rs 29.255 per unit. Industrial representatives sitting in the room watched these figures, and their faces carried one question: how will all this ultimately translate into their electricity bills? CPPA-G has projected an average Power Purchase Price (PPP) of Rs 27.309 per kWh for CY2027, the base-case scenario. But the real story is not in the 8 percent increase that headlines are chasing — the real story is in the Rs 1.914 trillion capacity charge that stands rock-solid in every scenario, whether oil is cheap or expensive.

Pakistan's power sector has been trapped for the past decade in a structural bind that is hard for the ordinary consumer to see. An estimated 130,081 GWh in sales, 2.6 percent demand growth, and a total power purchase cost of Rs 3.552 trillion — these numbers paint a picture of a system where the cost of keeping electricity ready exceeds the cost of generating it. In the base case, capacity charges are Rs 14.717 per unit, while fuel cost is just Rs 10.141 per unit. That is the ratio that received the least attention at the Nepra hearing and matters the most.

The six scenarios CPPA-G presented appear on the surface to be a play of fuel prices and exchange rate fluctuations. In the most optimistic scenario, where the RLNG and gas mix improves, PPP could drop to Rs 25.883 per unit. In the most pessimistic, where the dollar touches Rs 290 and fuel prices rise, it could climb to Rs 29.255. But the gap between these two ends is just Rs 3.372 per unit, while the capacity charge sits fixed at Rs 1.914 trillion — meaning no change in capacity charges even between the cheapest and most expensive scenarios. This is the arithmetic without which the electricity bill debate remains incomplete.

For me, the most interesting turn came when Nepra directed CPPA-G to revise KIBOR from 11.70 percent to 12 percent. This looks like a minor adjustment, but it means the entire scenario framework rests on financial market assumptions. CPPA-G itself acknowledged uncertainty in fuel availability, exchange rates, and future FCAs (Fuel Charges Adjustments). Nepra sought clarification on RLNG supply, dollar rates, Brent crude, and discrepancies in demand figures — a signal that the regulator itself does not treat these projections as final truth.

But one thing must be made clear: this 8 percent increase has not been approved yet. The figures that have emerged are CPPA-G's proposals, and the purpose of the Nepra hearing is to scrutinize these very proposals. Before the tariff rebasing takes effect on January 1, 2027, this process will determine what the consumer will actually pay. This step by Nepra — publicly challenging projections — is a rare example of accountability in Pakistan's energy sector, whatever the final outcome.

Rs 27.309 per Unit: The Real Story of Pakistan's Power Tariff Is Buried in Capacity Charges, Not Fuel

Now comes the angle that industrial representatives raised and which is the sharpest question. Aamir Sheikh demanded the immediate suspension of the incremental package and prospective application of FCAs. His argument is direct: this package benefits only a few select industries, while more than 90 percent of consumers bear its burden. This is the old game of cross-subsidy where one group makes another's electricity cheaper. And when FCAs can rise two to three times in winter, it becomes difficult for industries to even estimate their production costs.

Rs 27.309 per Unit: The Real Story of Pakistan's Power Tariff Is Buried in Capacity Charges, Not Fuel

A counter-intuitive point needs to be understood here: higher electricity prices do not mean the government collects more revenue. If consumers reduce consumption when bills rise, or move away from the grid to alternative sources, the same Rs 1.914 trillion capacity charge gets spread over fewer units — and per-unit cost rises further. CPPA-G's base case assumes 2.6 percent demand growth, but the sensitivity scenario drops it to just 0.70 percent. This is the feedback loop that was not seriously raised at the Nepra hearing — that expensive electricity can itself suppress demand, and lower demand can make capacity charges even heavier.

The real challenge before Nepra is not just forecasting fuel prices. Reconciling the demand discrepancies among CPPA-G, ISMO, and the Discos is most critical. If the demand forecast itself is wrong, the entire per-unit cost arithmetic goes awry. And until capacity charges are addressed — IPP contract renegotiation, capacity payment reform, and utilization rates — the hope of major consumer relief from cheaper fuel alone remains slim.

Those who reduce the electricity bill debate to just "8 percent increase" are seeing one corner of a larger picture. The real picture is that Pakistan's power sector is stuck in a system where keeping electricity ready is more expensive than generating it — and until the politics and economics of capacity charges are addressed, every tariff rebasing will bring a new debate without solving the old problem. Nepra has an opportunity in the coming months not just to correct projections, but to challenge the very framework in which the benefit of cheaper fuel never reaches the consumer. The question is: will it seize this opportunity, or once again get lost in the ebb and flow of numbers?

संबंधित खिलाड़ी